NARRATOR:
Although painted with meticulous naturalism, there is something unique and mysterious about this group of commonplace objects. Silhouetted against the darkness by a brilliant, almost unearthly light, the motifs seem suspended before us like objects of meditation. Placed with infinite care, they lead our eyes rhythmically from left to right: the tip of one lemon points up to the flowering sprig that crowns the beautifully delineated basket of oranges. Blossoms and leaves guide us across to the pewter plate with its white cup and single rose.
This remarkable painting by the 17th-century Spanish artist Francisco de Zurburán is his only signed and dated still life. It may actually be intended as a mystical evocation of the Virgin Mary. Oranges and orange blossoms symbolize her purity and chastity. The cup of water and smooth-stemmed rose also allude to her purity and love. The Virgin was often referred to as a “rose without thorns.” The cup, filled with water, symbolizes her role as the pure and sinless vessel worthy to bear the son of God.
This symbolism would have been understood instantly in the monastic communities that usually commissioned Zurburán’s works. The painting’s greatness lies, however, in the artist’s ability to endow these humble objects with an aura of profound spirituality.
Still Life with Lemons, Oranges and a Rose
1633
Francisco de Zurbarán (Spanish, 1598-1664)
On View
This extraordinary painting by Zurbarán, the only signed and dated still life by this great master of the school of Seville, has been widely admired as a masterpiece of the genre. To devout Spanish Catholics in the 17th century, the apparently humble objects portrayed here contained significant religious meaning. The measured placement of the three motifs, for example, would have been instantly understood as an allusion to the Holy Trinity. The painting has also been interpreted as an homage to the Virgin, with the oranges, their blossoms, and the cup of water symbolizing her purity, and the thornless rose referring to her Immaculate Conception.
Zurbarán depicted the physical character of the objects, and the space they inhabit, with unparalleled focus and skill. By modeling the rough-skinned yellow citrons with hints of green and russet, he suggests the fruit’s protuberance and weight. The arrangement of the orange leaves creates a rhythm of light and shadow, echoed again in the reflective surfaces of the pewter plates. Presented as a quiet, meditative piece within a shallow, minimally described space, this still life evokes a mystical intensity that transcends time in its appeal.
A recent cleaning has removed opaque layers of varnish and discolored retouches, revealing once again the clearly defined edges of the table, the four decorative inlays at each corner, and Zurbarán’s characteristic skill in describing the rough, textural skin of the citrus fruit. The welcome balance between the dark, atmospheric background, the warm tones of the fruit and basket, and the cooler tones of the silver plate and ceramic cup have been restored.
Click here to watch a video about the 2008 restoration of this painting.
Details
- Artist Name: Francisco de Zurbarán (Spanish, 1598-1664)
- Title: Still Life with Lemons, Oranges and a Rose
- Date: 1633
- Medium: Oil on canvas
- Dimensions: 24-1/2 x 43-1/8 in. (62.2 x 109.5 cm)
- Credit Line: The Norton Simon Foundation
- Accession Number: F.1972.06.P
- Copyright: © The Norton Simon Foundation
Object Information
Alexandre Antoine Ernest Journault (1836-1924), widower of Mme. Louise Henriette Aline Ferris Journault, nee Aline Kraft (d. 9 July 1921) (sale, Paris, Hôtel Drouot, 26 May 1922, lot 18, as Plat de cédrats, corbeille d’oranges, fleur et gobelet sur une table), sold for 2600 frs. to;
Legrand.
Count Alessandro Contini-Bonacossi, Florence, by 1930, by descent to;
Heirs of the Contini-Bonacossi Estate, Florence, to;
The Norton Simon Foundation.
Legrand.
Count Alessandro Contini-Bonacossi, Florence, by 1930, by descent to;
Heirs of the Contini-Bonacossi Estate, Florence, to;
The Norton Simon Foundation.
Gli Antichi Pittori Spagnoli della Collezione Contini Bonacossi
- Rome, Galleria Nazionale d'Arte, 1930 to
La Nature morte de l'antiquité à nos jours
- Paris, Orangerie des Tuileries, 1952-04 to 1952-06
Zurbaran
- Granada, 1953-06 to
Masterpieces of European Painting from the Norton Simon Museum
- The Frick Collection, 2009-02-10 to 2009-05-10
Reinstallation of Galleries: Art History of the 17th and 18th Century Gains Fresh Dimension
- Norton Simon Museum, 1993-09-02 to 1995-08-13
Significant Objects: The Spell of Still Life
- Norton Simon Museum, 2012-07-20 to 2013-01-21
- Mayer, August L., The Burlington Magazine, pp. 54, 55
- Mayer, August L., Apollo, p. 7
- Soria, Martin S., Gazette des Beaux-Arts, pp. 45-46
- Catturla, Maria Luisa, The Burlington Magazine, p. 303
- Seckel, Helmut P. G., Gazette des Beaux-Arts, fig. 2 pp. 281-286
- Seckel, Helmut P. G., Gazette des Beaux-Arts, p. 61
- Gaya Nuno, J., La pintura española fuera de España, no. 3010 pp. 338-339
- Gendel, M., Art News, p. 23
- San Francisco Sunday Examiner & Chronicle,
- Seldis, Henry, Los Angeles Times, pp. 50, 52
- Gudiol, J., Los Angeles Times, pp. 50, 52
- The Connoisseur, p. 307
- Young, E., The Burlington Magazine, pp. 207-208
- Nicolson, B., The Burlington Magazine, p. 536
- Brommer, Gerald, Discovering Art History, pp. 18-23
- Young, E., Apollo, pp. 435, 437
- Wilson, W., Los Angeles Times, pp. 101-102
- Baticle, J., Connaissance des Arts, pp. 30-43
- Taggard, M., Pantheon, pp. 76-80
- Brown, J., Francisco de Zurbaran, pl. 16
- Caturla, M. L.; and O. Delenda, Francisco de Zurbaran, n. 96, 97 pp. 110-101, 108, 248
- Museo Nacional d'Art, Catalon, Zurbaran, p. 32
- Young, Eric, The Connoisseur, p. 176-185
- Bettina Friedl, Creating Order: Arranging Objects into Meaning in Raphaelle Peale's Still Lifes,
- Amorós, J., Boletin Sociedad Espanola de Excursiones, 1927, pp. 133-142
- Longhi, Roberto; and August L. Meyer, Gli Antichi Pittori Spagnoli della collezione Contini Bonacossi, 1930, no. 65, pl. LXIV
- Guinard, P.; and J. Baticle, Histoire de la peinture espagnole, 1950, p. 167
- Soria, Martin S., The Paintings of Zurbaran, 1953, no. 71, fig. 47 pp. 14, 149-150
- Sterling, Charles, Still Life Painting from Antiquity to the Present Time, 1959, pp. 49, 71-72
- Kubler, George and Martin Soria, Art and Architecture of Spain and Portugal, 1500-1800, 1959, p. 246
- Guinard, P., Zurbaran et les peintres espagnols de la vie monastique, 1960, no. 594 p. 280
- Levey, Michael, A Concise History of Painting from Giotto to Cézanne, 1964, p. 193
- Torres Martin, R., La Naturaleza Muerta en la Pintura Espagnola, 1971, pp. 69-72, 125
- Held, Julius; and Donald Posner, 17th and 18th Century Art: Baroque Painting, Sculpture, Architecture, 1971, p. 178
- Dominique, F., Jardin des Arts, 1972, p. 44
- Frati, T.; and M. Gregori, L'opera completa di Zurbaran, 1973, no. 101
- Frankenstein, A., San Francisco Sunday Examiner & Chronicle, 1973,
- Artscanada, 1975, p. 44
- Laclotte, M.; and A. Perez Sanchez, Le larousse de grands peintres, 1976, pp. 439-440
- Trafalgar Galleries, In Light of Caravaggio, 1976, pp. 29, 34
- Royal Academy of Arts, The Golden Age of Painting, 1976, no. 39
- DeWeese-Wehen, J., Antique Monthly, 1977, p. 20C
- Cohen, A.; R. Cohen, E. Young and E. Cohen, Trafalgar Galleries at the Royal Academy II, 1979, pp. 64-66
- Moore, J., The Eastern Gate: An Invitation to the Arts of China and Japan, 1979, pp. 191-193
- Armstrong, R., Portfolio, 1980, p. 99
- Mullins, E., Great Paintings, 1981, pp. 18-23
- Ades, Dawn, Dali, 1982, no. 23 pp. 33, 210
- Kass, K., Morris Graves, Vision of the Inner Eye, 1983, p. 74
- Alpers, Svetlana, The Art of Describing: Dutch Art in the Seventeenth Century, 1983, p. 91
- Perez Sanchez, A., Pintura Española de Bodegones y Floreros de 1600 a Goya, 1983, pp. 75-76
- Janés, C., Los Genios de la Pintura Española: Zurbaran, 1984, pp. 8, 52, 93
- Brown, H., American Artist Magazine, 1986, p. 38
- Sullivan, E., Catalogue of Spanish Paintings: North Carolina Museum of Art, 1986, p. 92
- Ritschard, C., Pietro Sarto, perspectives empiriques, 1986, p. 127
- Bazin, G., Les fleurs vues par les peintres, 1987, pp. 87-88
- Burda, H., Pan, 1987, pp. 7-21
- Perez Sanchez, A., La nature morte espagnole du XVIIe siècle à Goya, 1987, p. 93
- De' Giorgio, Elsa, L'eredità Contini Bonacossi: L'ambiguo rigore del vero, 1988, fig. 40 pp. 311, 348
- Masterpieces from the Norton Simon Museum, 1989, pp. 46-47
- Bryson, Norman, Critical Inquiry, 1989, p. 239
- Bryson, Norman, Looking at the Overlooked: Four Essays on Still Life Painting, 1990, pp. 72-74
- Mallory, N., El Greco to Murillo, 1990, pp. 118-119
- Brown, Jonathan, The Golden Age of Painting in Spain, 1991, p. 99
- Brown, Jonathan, Francisco de Zurbaran, 1994, pp. 98-99
- Jordan, W. B. and P. Cherry, An Eye on Nature: Spanish Still Life from Velasquez to Goya, 1995, fig. 12.1 pp. 93-95, 101
- The National Gallery Report April 1996-March 1997, 1997, pp. 20-21
- Gallego, J. and J. Gudiol, Zurbaran, 1998, no. 83 pp. 34, 49, 56, 82
- Museo de Bellas Artes, El Bodegón Español [de Zurbarán a Picasso], 1999, pp. 37-39
- Friedl, Bettina, Negotiations of America's National Identity, 1999, fig. 1 pp. 56, 73, 75
- Gröschel, Claudia, Oranien-Orangen-Oranienbaum, 1999, fig. 13 p. 145
- Keck, Ray M., Love's Dialectic: Mimesis and Allegory in the Romances of Lope de Vega, 1999,
- Madoff, Steven Henry; and David Mamet, Donald Sultan: In the Still-Life Tradition, 1999, fig. 2 p. 12
- Minor, Vernon Hyde, Baroque & Rococo: Art & Culture, 1999, fig. 6.27 p. 247
- Ebert-Schifferer, Sybille, Still Life: A History, 1999, Fig. 132 p. 183
- Aronson, Steven M., Architectural Digest reprint, 200, pp. 56-58
- Lyons, Lisa, Departures: 11 Artists at the Getty, 2000, p. 10
- Morphet, Richard, Encounters: New Art from Old, 2000, fig. 7 pp. 80, 86-87
- IVAM Centre Julio González, Filippo de Pisis, 2000, pp. 18, 180
- Nature Morte, 2000, p. 65, jacket
- Understanding Paintings: Themes in Art Explored and Explained, 2000, p. 230; jacket cover (detail)
- Heilmeyer, Marina, The Language of Flowers: Symbols and Myths, 2001, pp. 89, 93
- Fernando Montes de Oca, L'age d'or du verve en France (The Golden Age of Glass in France), 2001, fig. 34 p. 32
- Wieke Schrover, et al., M e M o, 2002, p. 74
- Nationalmuseum, Spanish Masters and their Followers, 2002, fig. 4 p. 76
- Campbell, Katie, Marmalade Season, 2003, Cover
- Moss, Stanley, The History of Color, 2003, Cover
- Luginbuhl, Gregg, Teaching Peace: Nonviolence and the Liberal Arts, 2003, fig. 8 p. 156
- Harris, Ann Sutherland, 17th Century Art & Architecture, 2004, fig. 3.20 p. 215
- Aronson, Steven M., Architectural Digest, 2006, pp. 56-58
- Ebert-Schifferer, Sybille, Important Old Master Painting Part I Including J.M.W. Turner's "Giudecca, La Donna della Salute and San Giorgio" Thursday 6 April 2006, 2006, fig. 17 p. 127
- Harris, Ann Sutherland, 17th Century Art & Architecture (2nd edition), 2008, fig. 3.26 p. 222-3, 248
- Campbell, Sara, Collector Without Walls: Norton Simon and His Hunt for the Best, 2010, cat. 769 p. 337
- Neuman, Robert, Baroque and Rococo Art and Architecture, 2012, Fig. 5.10 p. 156
- Wilmerding, John, The Pop Object: The Still Life Tradition in Pop Art, 2013, p. 19
- Aterido, Ángel, Juan Fernández el Labrador, Naturalezas muertas, 2013, Fig.19 p. 57
- Ignacio Cano, Gabriele Finaldi, Odile Delenda, Zurbaran (1598-1664), 2014, Fig. 3 p. 20
- Odile Delenda and Mar Borobia, Zurbarán: una nueva mirada, 2015, fig. 5 p. 22
- Rafael Romero Asenjo, The Unique Qualities of an Extraordinary Still Life in the Naseiro Collection: A Contribution to its Technical Analysis, 2015, Figures 9 and 10 p. #16, 17
- Paulette Tavormina, Paulette Tavormina: Seizing Beauty, 2016, p. #14
- Various authors, edited by Mark Rogián, Spanish Art in America, 2016, pp. 192-193 ; p. [188] (ill.), p. 190 (ill.), p. 193 (ill.)
- essay by Susan Galassi, Zurbarán: Jacob and His Twelve Sons, Paintings from Auckland Castle, 2017, Fig. 54 pp. 102-103, 182
- Lane Relyea, Adam McEwen, Heidi Zuckerman, Wayne Koestenbaum, etal., Adam McEwen: I Think I'm in Love, 2017, Fig. 3 p. 61 ; p. 63 (ill.)
- Rothkopf, Scott, Owens, Laura, 2017, pp. 478-479
- Weber, Dr. Gregor, Rembrandt-Velázquez : Dutch and Spanish Masters, 2019, Fig. 1 p. 138; p. 139 (ill.)
- Nicolas Milovanovic, les arts en Europe au XVII siecle, 2021, Notice 36 pp. 158 - 159 (ill.)
- Salvador Zaragoza / Vicente Todolí ed., Los Cítricos: Un viaje a través de la historia y del arte, 2023, pp. 182-`83 (ill.)
Related Media
Image reproduction permission may be granted for scholarly or arts related commercial use. All image requests, regardless of their intended purpose, should be submitted via the reproduction request form.
Images may be protected by copyright and other intellectual property rights. Additional permission may be required.
Please allow up to four weeks for your request to be reviewed. Approved requests for the reproduction of an image will receive a contract detailing all fees and conditions of use of the image. Upon receipt of both the signed contract and full payment, the Office of Rights and Reproductions will provide the image. A complimentary copy of the published material must be provided to the Norton Simon Museum.